Why community self management will work
This system works best for games with a large amount of players in a sandbox-like environment, so its difficult to implement into other types of games, although League of Legends found an effective method. But for sandbox games such as:- DayZ
- Arma RP servers
- Minecraft servers
- Garry's Mod RP servers
- and just about any MMO game
These games can use this system to allow players to play the game longer, by establishing a commitment with the community by helping create and amend rules of play. When the rules continue to change, the play-style of the game continues to change, giving the game strong replay-ability.
If the community can decide the rules in which players should behave, then the rules will have the potential of becoming far more balanced than any developer could achieve. Players can adjust the rules when they find an exploit or new in-game content that may change play styles.
When players are the ones enforcing the rules, it will still be possible for to break the rules, but with that comes the high risk of getting caught and receiving harsh punishment. High risk keeps the game entertaining, griefing can be an entertainment factor for players; so breaking the rules is an option, but it cannot be done frequently.
Possible Downside
It could be difficult for players to collaborate to establish their own governing system, so developers could use some tools such as the behavior modification examples used in League of Legends to reward and punish players to achieve this system.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis is a good theory you have here. It would be nice to join a game of Minecraft with a friend and not have to worry about that kind of thing. The idea sound good but I do not think it will work with most game without a lot of work.
ReplyDeleteSome players will always be willing to break the rules for one reason or another, the punishment would not hurt them personally just there in game self. Those players could just move on to another server, community or change an account. No matter what, there will always be someone who will try to break the system.